Best Budget Toaster Oven: 4 Bargain Picks Starting Under $70

The best budget toaster oven pick is the BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake TO1787SS, the only model here with 5-in-1 air frying, a two-year warranty, and Amazon’s Choice status, all still under $70.

We compared four models that actually deliver on “budget”, not appliances that get called cheap and then ring up at $150. Every price, star rating, and stock status below comes from a verified Amazon listing screenshot taken this week, not a search snippet or a manufacturer’s press page.

None of us claim to have run these four best budget toaster oven picks side by side ourselves. Instead, we cross-checked specs against live Amazon listing data and pulled outside performance context from Consumer Reports and Tasting Table, both linked below where relevant.

By the end of this best budget toaster oven guide, you’ll know exactly which of the four fits your kitchen, your budget, and whether you actually need air fry at all.

One thing you won’t find here: first-person claims about running our own comparisons or specific cook times we invented. Every performance detail traces back to a verified spec sheet, an Amazon listing, or a named outside source.

Table of Contents

• Top Picks at a Glance
• What to Look For in the Best Budget Toaster Oven With Air Fryer
• BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake TO1787SS
• Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp 31403
• Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 31344DA
• Oster 10 Function Air Fryer Oven
• Side-by-Side Comparison
• Toaster Oven vs Air Fryer Toaster Oven
• Which One Should You Choose
• FAQ
• Final Verdict

What to Look For in the Best Budget Toaster Oven With Air Fryer

Not every “budget” toaster oven earns the label. Here’s what actually separates a solid $60–$90 pick from one that’ll frustrate you within a month, and what to skip paying extra for.

We’re covering six criteria below: capacity, air fry, price, cleaning, timers and safety, and warranty. Skim the headings if you already know what matters most to you.

Capacity and Interior Size

Most cheap toaster oven under $100 models fit 4 slices of bread or a 9-inch pizza, fine for one or two people. If you’re feeding a family, you’ll want something closer to the Oster’s 12-inch pizza capacity instead.

Worth knowing: Amazon’s own spec sheet for one listing here shows a capacity field that doesn’t match its real-world interior size. Treat any single capacity number as a rough guide, and cross-reference it against the stated slice count or pizza size instead.

• Compact (4-slice): Best for singles, couples, or dorm-style kitchens with limited counter space.
• Large (6-slice+): Better for families of three or more, or anyone who batch-cooks on weekends.

Air Fry Function: Worth the Extra $10–$20?

Two of our four best budget toaster oven picks skip air fry entirely and stick to bake, broil, and toast. That’s not a downside if you already own a dedicated air fryer, it just means you’re paying for a simpler machine with fewer parts to break. If you’re weighing a standalone unit instead of a combo, our Ninja AF101 review covers the most popular dedicated model at a similar price point.

If you don’t own a separate air fryer, the extra $10–$20 for an air-fry-capable model like the Black+Decker or Sure-Crisp usually pays for itself the first time you crisp frozen fries without pulling out a second appliance.

One caveat applies across nearly every best budget toaster oven with air fryer, not just these four: the basket doesn’t circulate air as aggressively as a dedicated countertop air fryer. Expect solid results on fries and frozen snacks, not restaurant-level crisping on a whole chicken.

Price: What Counts as a Cheap Toaster Oven Under $100

Consumer Reports notes that toaster ovens in their ratings run from about $20 to around $450, so everything in this best budget toaster oven roundup, capped at $88.87, sits firmly in true budget territory, not just discounted-premium territory.

Most of the price gap between a $60 model and a $200 model comes down to a digital display, extra rack positions, and a longer warranty, not dramatically better toasting or baking performance.

That’s the real story behind most “budget vs premium” toaster oven debates: once you’re past the $60 floor, you’re paying for convenience features and cosmetic upgrades far more than you’re paying for cooking results. If you’d rather compare a dedicated air fryer against a full-size oven first, our air fryer vs oven comparison breaks down that tradeoff separately.

Ease of Cleaning

A removable crumb tray is non-negotiable at any price point, and every pick in this best budget toaster oven roundup includes one. Beyond that, door style makes the biggest difference in day-to-day cleanup.

Interior finish matters too, a light-colored or non-stick interior shows grease buildup faster than a dark stainless one, so wipe-downs after every second or third use will keep any of these four best budget toaster oven picks looking new longer.

• Roll-top doors: stay up and out of the way, so spills and drips land less often on the door itself.
• Drop-down doors: the more common style, and still easy to wipe with a damp cloth after each use.

Timer, Auto Shutoff, and Safety Features

Every model here includes an auto-shutoff timer, which matters more than it sounds, a forgotten setting can scorch bread or worse. The Black+Decker and Sure-Crisp run 30-minute dials; the Easy Reach and Oster stretch closer to 60 minutes for longer bakes.

• Short timers (30 min): fine for toast, frozen snacks, and quick reheats.
• Longer timers (60 min): better suited to casseroles, roasts, or a full tray of cookies.

Warranty and Long-Term Reliability

Warranty length is one of the clearest budget-vs-premium signals in this category. Most models in a best budget toaster oven search carry a one-year warranty, while the Black+Decker here stands out with a two-year limited warranty at the same price tier as its one-year competitors.

Reliability data at this price point mostly comes from review volume rather than long-term lab data, so we weighted review count alongside star rating when ranking these four best budget toaster oven picks.

Cooking Functions and Controls

Knob controls are the norm at this price point, and that’s not a downside, fewer digital menus mean fewer components that can fail. The Oster is the exception here, with a digital display and 10 total cooking presets against 5, 4, and 3 for the other three picks.

If you’ve ever fumbled through a digital menu at 7am trying to toast a bagel, you’ll appreciate what a simple two-knob layout gets right: temperature on one dial, function and time on the other, no submenus involved. More presets doesn’t automatically mean a better toaster, it mostly means more ways to reach the same handful of results.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Laid out side by side, the pattern across this best budget toaster oven lineup is clear: price climbs with capacity, not with rating. The two Hamilton Beach models actually out-rate the pricier Black+Decker and Oster, which says more about review volume and consistency than raw cooking power.

Which One Should You Choose?

Still torn between two of these four? Here’s the quick-reference version, broken down by the exact situation each best budget toaster oven pick handles best.

Choose the BLACK+DECKER TO1787SS if:

• You want the longest warranty and Amazon’s Choice status in this price range.
• You cook mostly toast, frozen snacks, and small weeknight meals.
• You’re fine with a 250°F floor, since most everyday cooking sits well above that anyway.

Choose the Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp 31403 if:

• Price is your single biggest factor.
• You want a lower 200°F floor for slower cooking.
• You want the widest low-temperature range of any pick in this best budget toaster oven roundup.

Choose the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 31344DA if:

• You never use air fry and want the strongest rating on the list.
• You want the roll-top door for easier, safer access.
• You prefer simple, dial-only controls over digital menus.

Choose the Oster 10 Function if:

• You cook for three or more people regularly.
• You want the widest range of cooking presets, including tender roast and dehydrate.
• You prefer a digital display over knob controls.

Final Verdict: The Best Budget Toaster Oven 2026

The BLACK+DECKER Crisp ‘N Bake TO1787SS is our overall pick, it’s the longest-warrantied, most air-fry-versatile option under $70. Tasting Table’s own budget roundup reaches a similar conclusion, singling out this same Black+Decker line for consolidating an air fryer and toaster oven into one appliance.

Tightest budget? Go with the Sure-Crisp at $59.95.

Cooking for a family? The Oster’s 12-inch capacity and 10 functions are worth the extra $23.

Don’t need air fry at all? The Easy Reach’s 4.4★ rating and roll-top door make it the strongest pick for straightforward toasting and baking, no extra features required.

As an Amazon Associate, homeapplianceowl.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and stock status were verified at the time of publication and may change.

We’ll revisit this best budget toaster oven guide as prices shift or any of these four go out of stock, so check back if you’re reading this more than a few months out.